On dimensions of ecological economics
نویسنده
چکیده
a r t i c l e i n f o A recent paper (Ecological Economics 69, 2010, pp. 1604–1609) has addressed the issues of dimensional homo-geneity of equations and non-linear transformations of variables in economic and ecological economic models. The authors argued that logarithmic transformation cannot be used when variables are dimensional, presented several examples of purportedly incorrect use in applied economics and ecological economics publications, and concluded that these applications " make no sense. " In this paper we show that this view goes against well established theory and practice of many disciplines including physics, statistics, biology, and economics, and rests on an inadequate understanding of dimensional homogeneity and the nature of empirical modeling in applied sciences. We believe that it is important to clarify that the use of dimensional variables in transcendental functions is in fact in accordance with the established scientific consensus so as to prevent further confusion from arising in ecological economics where addressing complex problems requires the synthesis of insights from many diverse disciplines to further our understanding of the environment–economy interface. We also provide novel applications of dimensional methods to ecological economics and useful methodological references from several strands of scientific literature, not previously systematically consolidated, that should be of interest to every applied researcher. To further our understanding of the interdependence between the economy and the environment, ecological economics often seeks mathematical relationships among quantities that describe the phenomena under investigation. These quantities, variables and constants in our models, will often be dimensional in nature, i.e., their numerical value depends on the unit of measurement chosen. In a recent paper, pub-Mayumi and Giampietro, hereinafter referred to as M&G, using arguments based on the Taylor's theorem of calculus, argued that exponential and logarithmic functions can only be applied to dimensionless numbers. They then reviewed several economics and ecological economics papers published over the past 50 years where this precept is purportedly not followed, resulting in applications that, according to the authors, " make no sense, " and concluded that " it is unfortunate that many empirical and theoretical studies in economics, as well as in ecological economics, use dimensional numbers in exponential or logarithmic functions " and that " economists concerned with the biophysical and monetary aspects of ecological and economic interactions must understand the importance of dimensional homogeneity. " These are extraordinary claims that, if correct, would imply that most applications of …
منابع مشابه
Does educational quality drive ecological performance? Case of high and low developed countries
The study attempts to assess the impact of the educational level of the country’s population, the level of science and technology development on the general environmental environment. The aim of this article is to assess the impact of educational level and level of science development on individual elements that reflect the state of the environment. To receive the obtained results is being used...
متن کاملOffering a Pattern of Ecotourism Management Pattern with an Emphasis on the Urban Ecological Textures (Case Study: District 9 of Isfahan’s Municipality)
As it can take an efficient step towards the preservation and sustainability of such lands due to the preparation, implementation, and reformation of criteria. In District 9 of Isfahan Municipality, mismanagement in the preservation of ecological lands has destroyed gardens and agricultural lands, and has caused the loss of social unity of neighborhoods. Consequently, the study of ecotourism m...
متن کاملThe Relationship Between Gender Inequality and Happiness in Iran\'s Provinces: An Ecological Study
Background and Aim: In 2020 the rank of Iran in happiness index and gender inequality were reported to be rather low, they being, among 153 countries, 118 and 113, respectively. This study aimed to investigate the relationship between gender inequality and happiness in Iran's provinces. Materials and Methods: This ecological study was conducted based on secondary analysis of data on happiness ...
متن کاملMeasure and comparison of economic, social and ecological sustainability of farming systems in the Marvdasht plain
Agricultural sustainability refers to the ability of a cropping system to produce, without causing irreversible damage tothe ecosystem. There is an increasing need to view cropping systems and identify management practices in a holisticindicator-based impact assessment. The main objective of this study was to compare and rank the cropping systems of theMarvdasht plain in Fars Province; in order...
متن کاملSustainable Management of Saravan Sylvan Park Using Stochastic Dynamic Programming
The present study sustainable management of Guilan Saravan Sylvan Park was planned. The used method in the form of decision support model in three10-year period was studied for parks of various states and with considering the economic, ecological and social criteria during the years 2008 to 2038. By using hierarchical fuzzy analysis method, the reaching to an optimal level of economic, ecologic...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2015